Bioenergy technologies in long-run climate change mitigation: results from the EMF-33 study

Bioenergy is expected to play an important role in long-run climate change mitigation strategies as highlighted by many integrated assessment model (IAM) scenarios. These scenarios, however, also show a very wide range of results, with uncertainty about bioenergy conversion technology deployment and biomass feedstock supply. To date, the underlying differences in model assumptions and parameters for the range of results have not been conveyed. Here we explore the models and results of the 33rd study of the Stanford Energy Modeling Forum to elucidate and explore bioenergy technology specifications and constraints that underlie projected bioenergy outcomes. 

We first develop and report consistent bioenergy technology characterizations and modeling details. We evaluate the bioenergy technology specifications through a series of analyses—comparison with the literature, model intercomparison, and an assessment of bioenergy technology projected deployments. We find that bioenergy technology coverage and characterization varies substantially across models, spanning different conversion routes, carbon capture and storage opportunities, and technology deployment constraints. Still, the range of technology specification assumptions is largely in line with bottom-up engineering estimates.

We then find that variation in bioenergy deployment across models cannot be understood from technology costs alone. Important additional determinants include biomass feedstock costs, the availability and costs of alternative mitigation options in and across end-uses, the availability of carbon dioxide removal possibilities, the speed with which large scale changes in the makeup of energy conversion facilities and integration can take place, and the relative demand for different energy services.


PBL Authors
Vassilis Daioglou Detlef van Vuuren
Other authors
Steven K. Rose
Nico Bauer
Alban Kitous
Matteo Muratori
Fuminori Sano
Shinichiro Fujimori
Matthew J. Gidden
Etsushi Kato
Kimon Keramidas
David Klein
Florian Leblanc
Junichi Tsutsui
Marshal Wise


Publication title
Bioenergy technologies in long-run climate change mitigation: results from the EMF-33 study
Publication date
24 August 2020
Publication type
Publication language
Climatic Change
volume 163, pages1603–1620(2020)
Product number