Global Transition, Local Realities

Governance tensions in energy transition value chains

The global energy transition is reshaping relationships between countries that produce critical minerals and green hydrogen, and those that consume them. These relationships create opportunities for investment and industrialisation in producing countries, but also tensions around how benefits, burdens, and development opportunities are distributed. This PBL report examines how these tensions affect the development objectives of resource-producing countries, and what this implies for the policies of the consuming regions like the European Union (EU) and the Netherlands.  

mining impacts

Our analysis draws on four case studies conducted by local researchers, covering green hydrogen in Egypt and South Africa, and lithium mining in Ghana and Nigeria. The recently developed Justice–Direction–Responsibility (JDR) framework structures the analysis of these cases around three questions: what is at stake and for whom? What kind of change is being pursued? And, who should act, and on what grounds?

Opportunities and outcomes on the ground

The case evidence suggests that transition objectives are not always aligned with producing countries’ own development priorities. Formal governance arrangements are often in place, but consultations were described as informational rather than participatory, with benefits framed as future outcomes rather than conditions for project approval. Producing countries have the ambition to process minerals domestically, yet infrastructure, financing, and offtake agreements are designed primarily to supply consuming countries: lithium leaves as unprocessed concentrate or ore, and hydrogen goes mainly to Europe.

Governance tensions

The study identifies three recurring governance tensions. First, formal commitments, such as consultation and benefit-sharing agreements, do not automatically translate into local benefits. Second, projects are often built for export, while producing countries prioritise domestic development and local value addition. Third, responsibility for social and environmental impacts is dispersed across financiers, buyers, and governments, while the impacts fall on the people living near mines and production sites, often before any benefits arrive.

What this means for Dutch and EU engagement

Consuming-country instruments are stronger on supply security than on development.. Offtake contracts and trade agreements carry legally binding terms, whereas Strategic Partnerships and Global Gateway carry development ambitions without enforceable conditions. The central policy challenge for the Netherlands and the EU is therefore not only to secure the resources the transition needs, but also to consider how the conditions attached to finance, partnerships and trade shape development opportunities in producing countries.

Specifications

Publication title
Global Transition, Local Realities
Publication subtitle
Governance tensions in energy transition value chains
Publication date
18 November 2026
Publication type
Report
Publication language
English
Product number
6097